Activated charcoal toothpaste breaking tubesPosted by bayo1214 on July 29, 2021 at 10:13 pm
what did you think was responsible for activated charcoal toothpaste breaking tubes
MemberJuly 29, 2021 at 10:15 pm
Without an ingredient list…we can only speculate mechanical or defective material damage…but I don’t think that was your question.
You are asking if an ingredient (or combination of) did this? If so…also include material that tube is made of. The chemist cannot answer….without any clues.
MemberJuly 29, 2021 at 10:42 pmMATERIALSSorbitolGlycerinBinderSaccharinBenzoateFlouridePEGThickner SilicaAbrassive SilicaSLSProsense Freeze FlavourActivated CharcoalWater
MemberAugust 3, 2021 at 5:44 pm
Activated charcoal can be very adsorbent. This means that if you open a zip lock bag, put 500 grams of good quality activated charcoal inside, seal the zip lock shut, when you come back in 10 hours the zip lock can be all wrinkled and look like it’s become vacuum sealed.
This adsorbency is what also helps gives it it’s wonderful properties.
I am not an expert on cosmetic materials or tube materials, but I know charcoal and there is a chance that the suction force caused by adsorption can degrade the structural integrity of your plastic tube.
A simple way to test this further, you can use 500g of your activated charcoal to see if it does create a vacuum seal in a ziplock bag. If it doesn’t, it’s probably not that adsorbent and less likely to cause that packaging structural degradation. Hope this helps.
MemberAugust 3, 2021 at 5:58 pm
Tracy9, thanks for this succinct response, this is helpful, I also discover some of the tube swollen up, that is creating air vacuum in the tube though I’m still trying to do some studies to know what is the exacts course of this two observation.
MemberAugust 3, 2021 at 9:42 pm
I am no expert….but sounds like…. You are using a lot more Charcoal then they would in US formulas….where they just put a touch in…for claim (cudos).
Sounds like you might need to hydrate it…before formulating with it….so the morphing occurs before entering the final packaging. Again…I am no expert!
MemberAugust 3, 2021 at 9:47 pm
Ok thanks I appreciate your contribution and time