Here is a formula for a liquid preservative system I developed and used in a wide variety of personal care items, including gels, creams and shampoo/Bath formulas for years. It never failed.
Propylene Glycol 66%
Methyl Paraben 11%
Propyl Paraben 3%
Phenoxyethanol 20%
Procedure:
Phase A
Heat Propylene Glycol and add with mixing Methyl Paraben and Propy Paraben until Parabens are completely dissolved and mixture is clear.
Phase B
Cool to below 40C and add Phenoxyethanol with mixing.
Finished product will be crystal clear, and extremely effective.
Use percentage, depending on certain types of actives, between 0.5% - 1.5%.
I hope this helps.