Experimentation is one of the keys to success in cosmetic chemistry. I’ll give more details on
that below.
One of the others is knowing your raw materials. At a bare minimum, you should have a
Technical Data Sheet (TDS), a Specification Sheet and/or a Certificate of
Analysis, and a Safety Data Sheet (formerly a MSDS) for each and every one of
your ingredients. Ideally, you would have read and kept a copy of all of the
supplier literature available for every chemical (and not just the literature
from your supplier) that you are using.
After you have (at least) read all of the technical data sheets, it should be a little easier to
fix your formula, For example, in your formula, one of the ingredients that
provides thickening is Glucamate VLT. Here’s the experimentation part - you
need to make a series of batches that use increasing amounts of Glucamate VLT
until you have reached a viscosity you are comfortable with. Then you need to
duplicate this experiment with any other thickeners you’re using. Then, you
need to see if any of the thickeners are synergistic with each other. By this
point, you should be fairly comfortable with using the chemicals that thicken
your batch, and you will be able to answer your own question.