Thanks for responding! The only ingredients that are soluble in water in the shampoo bar are glycerin at 2% and a clay powder for color at 1%. The only ingredients soluble in water in the conditioner bar are honeyquat (Hydroxypropyltrimonium Honey) at 4%, bamboo bioferment (Lactobacillus/Arundinaria gigantea Ferment Filtrate) at 8% and 1% clay powder.
I suppose the shampoo bar might not need a preservative but I’ve read in several forums that because shampoo and conditioner bars come into contact with water they need one and I’ve heard of a few cases of bars without proper drainage molding over.
Wouldn’t a product still have a pH if it even has a few ingredients soluble in water? Both bars tested around 5 when I checked with my meter though I haven’t yet learned how to professionally test the pH for more accurate results.