Which of these two formulas would be milder as baby shampoo & bodywash

Which of these two formulas would be milder and better option as a baby shampoo and bodywash?
By milder i mean milder for skin lipids and protein. 

A in active surfactant 
SLES 5.25%
CAPB 0.75%
HPMC 0.5%
Cationic guar 0.075%
NACL 4%
Formalin 0.1%(370ppm formaldehyde)
Citric acid 
Water 
pH 5 
Total 6% surfactant at 7:1 ratio 

B in active surfactant
SLES 3%
CAPB 0.75%
Sodium stearoyl lactylate 0.5%
HPMC 0.5%
NACL 3%
Formalin 0.1%(370ppm formaldehyde)
Citric acid 
Water 
pH 5
Total 4.25% surfactants at 4:1:0.7 ratio 

Tagged:

Comments

  • PharmaPharma Member, Pharmacist
    Both wouldn't be allowed in the EU and both don't look 'mild' to me. Ah well, the world is overpopulated anyway...
  • Pharma said:
    Both wouldn't be allowed in the EU and both don't look 'mild' to me. Ah well, the world is overpopulated anyway...
    I will not sell it in Europe and all these ingredients are allowed here.

    Is it because of formalin or something else in the formula that you think it is not mild? 

    My another preservative option is CMI MI but i think formalin is milder than CMI MI. 
Sign In or Register to comment.